2023 is the year that teaches how this market prices — because it behaved opposite to the textbook. Demand cooled and a primary buyer cohort stepped back, and standard logic says prices should fall. For quality firms, they didn't. This single-year case sits inside the broader new-normal thesis.
§ 01 · The setup for compressionEverything pointed down.
The conditions all pointed toward lower prices. Deal volume stepped materially down from the 2021 peak, continuing the post-bubble moderation. PE-backed buyers — roughly 70% of deal activity — pulled back as several long-time players moved to the sidelines to navigate debt positions and integration backlogs, and the survivors became far more selective about deploying newly finite capital. A volume decline, a primary buyer cohort restructuring, and a higher cost of capital: by any standard framework, that combination should compress multiples meaningfully.
§ 02 · Why they heldThree structural factors.
Instead, the quality multiple held. Three structural factors explain it.
The multiple-arbitrage flywheel. The large publicly traded brokers — the proxy for PE platform valuations — kept trading at premium multiples, near 18× EBITDA. As long as the exit-side multiple holds, the entry-side holds: a PE buyer can pay 12–13× for an agency because the earnings will trade at 18–20× when folded into a platform or sold on. Record seller profitability. What buyers were paying for got materially better — private brokers posted record organic growth and EBITDA margins above 20%, so higher-quality earnings justified persistent multiples even as buyer count thinned. And demand softened but didn't collapse: the field still held 35-plus active national-scale buyers working hard to close. Soft is not the same as weak.
| 2023 valuation resilience | Value |
|---|---|
| Quality $3M–$10M multiple | ~12.5× EBITDA (flat vs prior year) |
| Public-broker EBITDA multiple | ~18× |
| Public-broker revenue multiple | ~5.6× |
| Active national-scale buyers | 35+ |
| Private-broker EBITDA margins | 20%+ |
§ 03 · Quality polarizationWhat actually changed.
The real 2023 story wasn't market-wide compression — it was quality polarization. Multiples for quality brokerages held; multiples for mediocre firms compressed materially. Quality books drew competitive processes with multiple credible bidders at full multiples; weaker firms faced far fewer suitors, lower valuations, and willing-buyer-only dynamics. After the 2020–2022 "everyone gets bid" environment, that divergence was a substantial change — buyers became far more selective about which firms they would court aggressively. The arbitrage math underneath it all is detailed in modern valuation methodologies.
Falling volume didn't lower prices — it sharpened the question. In 2023 the market stopped asking "is it for sale?" and started asking "is it any good?" — and only the second question moved a multiple.
§ 04 · What it means for sellersQuality is the variable.
The lesson is direct: in a polarized market, listing quality is the load-bearing variable. A mediocre book faces buyer indifference; a quality book still draws competitive bidding at full multiples — so the value-realization work shifts decisively to demonstrable book quality, retention, organic growth, and producer depth. With the buyer field thinner but still competitive, match quality matters more than ever — surfacing the right buyers for the right book on transparent criteria becomes the difference between a competitive process and a single willing buyer. The year-end retrospective that confirmed the resilience held into 2024 is the golden-era snapshot.
◆
Terminology on this shelf
- Multiple-arbitrage flywheel
- The mechanism where high public-broker exit multiples support the entry multiples PE pays for acquisitions.
- Quality polarization
- The 2023 pattern where quality firms held their multiples while mediocre ones compressed.
- Willing-buyer-only dynamics
- The weak-firm market state of few suitors and no competitive tension, versus quality firms' multi-bidder processes.
- Public-broker multiple
- The trading multiple of large listed brokers — a proxy for PE valuations and the flywheel's exit side.