Insurance agency · Port St Lucie, Florida
McGarr Insurance
An insurance agency in Port St Lucie, Florida, founded in 2019.
Agency details
- Address
- 493 SW Port St Lucie Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL 34953
- Website
- mcgarrinsurance.com
- Lines of business
- Personal
- Carriers
- Allstate Insurance Group, Anchor Property & Casualty Insurance Company, Bankers Insurance Group, Berkshire Hathaway, Cabrillo Holding Group, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Cypress Group Holdings Inc Group, Florida Peninsula Holdings Group, Frontline Insurance Group, Hale Partnership Group, Hci Group Inc, Heritage Insurance Holdings Group, Liberty Mutual Group, Lilypad Insurance Holdings Group, Mangrove Property Insurance Company, MD Group, Mercury Gen Group, National General, Progressive Group, Safepoint Holdings Inc Group, Slide Insurance Holdings Group, Southern Oak Insurance Company, Sypher Insurance Exchange, Tower Hill Insurance Group, Travelers Group, Trident Reciprocal Exchange, Trusted Resource Underwriters Group, Universal Insurance Holding Group
- Founded
- 2019
- License
- Licensed in Florida since 2019
- Staff
- 3
- Licensed P&C producers
- 1 (1 also licensed for life, 1 for health)
- States served
- Florida
Team
- Matt McGarrOwner
- Jennifer SanchezProducer
- Melinda WhiteProducer
Is this your agency?
See what your book is worth, and claim this page to correct its details or take it down. We confirm every claim before anything on the page changes.
Named on this page and want to be taken off it, or run this agency and want the page taken down? Request removal.
Page last updated October 17, 2026.
Explore Your Options
Ready to take the next step?
Whether you're looking to sell, buy, or value your insurance book of business, we're here to help.
Selling an Agency
Learn how to sell your insurance book of business and connect with qualified buyers in Florida.
Learn more about sellingBuying an Agency
Discover opportunities to grow your agency through strategic acquisitions in Florida.
Learn more about buyingGetting a Valuation
Get a free, instant valuation of your insurance book to understand its true market value.
Get my valuation